The Wild Bill Hickok shootout and Springfield's Wild West era
One of the museum's marquee exhibits covers the July 21, 1865 shootout between Wild Bill Hickok and Davis Tutt on Park Central Square — directly outside the museum's current location. The shootout is generally credited as the first "quick-draw" duel in the American Wild West and is one of the most thoroughly documented gunfights of the era. Hickok and Tutt, both Civil War veterans living in Springfield in the immediate post-war period, quarreled over gambling debts and a personal disagreement involving a pocket watch. They met on the square at approximately 6pm on July 21, 1865; Tutt fired first and missed, Hickok returned fire at a range of about 75 yards and struck Tutt in the chest, killing him instantly.
The Hickok exhibit includes archival documents from the subsequent trial (Hickok was charged with manslaughter and acquitted on grounds of self-defense), period photographs of Park Central Square in the 1860s and 1870s, and interpretive panels about the broader Wild West cultural mythology that grew up around the event. Hickok left Springfield shortly after the trial and continued his career as a frontier scout, lawman, and gambler before his death in Deadwood, South Dakota in 1876.
Beyond the Hickok shootout, the museum's Wild West gallery covers Springfield's role as a frontier commercial center in the 1860s through 1880s — cattle drives, railroad construction, frontier banking, and the gradual transition from frontier town to established commercial city. Springfield's pre-Route 66 history is the kind of substantive Wild West content that makes the museum a worthwhile stop even for visitors whose primary interest is the Mother Road era.